Practice · AQA 7402 · Paper 3 essay · 25 marks

A-level Biology essay examples: original annotated AQA responses

Two essay titles, each written at Level 5 and Level 3. The comment under each paragraph says what it earns.

The importance of speed and rate in biological processes

Level 5 · 22 of 25

Five distinct areas, each linked to speed or rate in its opening sentence and explained at A-level depth. No framing paragraphs and no errors. The populations paragraph could say more about carrying capacity, which keeps it off full marks.

Without enzymes, metabolic reactions would happen at far too slow a rate to keep cells alive at body temperature. An enzyme lowers the activation energy by forming an enzyme-substrate complex: in the induced-fit model the active site changes shape slightly as the substrate binds, putting strain on its bonds. Raising the temperature increases the rate because molecules have more kinetic energy and collide successfully more often, but above the optimum the hydrogen and ionic bonds holding the tertiary structure break, the active site changes shape and the enzyme is denatured. Cells also control rates: in end-product inhibition the product of a pathway acts as a non-competitive inhibitor of an early enzyme, binding away from the active site and slowing the whole pathway when enough product has been made.

Links rate to survival at once, then explains activation energy, temperature and denaturation precisely (denatured, not killed) and adds control of rate by inhibition.

The speed of a nerve impulse decides how quickly an animal can respond. In a myelinated axon the Schwann cells' myelin sheath insulates the membrane, so depolarisation happens only at the nodes of Ranvier and the impulse jumps from node to node by saltatory conduction, which is much faster than in a non-myelinated axon. A wider axon has less resistance to the flow of ions, which is why animals without myelin, such as squid, have giant axons for escape responses. Temperature matters too, because ions diffuse faster when warmer. The refractory period sets a limit on how many impulses can pass per second and makes sure each impulse is separate and travels one way.

Three factors affecting speed, each with its mechanism, plus the refractory period as a limit on rate.

Size decides whether diffusion is fast enough. By Fick's law, the rate of diffusion is proportional to surface area times the difference in concentration, divided by the thickness of the exchange surface. A single-celled organism has a large surface area to volume ratio and a short diffusion distance, so diffusion across its surface supplies oxygen fast enough. As organisms get larger their surface area to volume ratio falls, so they have specialised surfaces such as alveoli, gill lamellae or insect tracheoles, each with a large surface area and a very short diffusion pathway, to keep the rate of gas exchange high enough for their metabolic rate.

Uses Fick's law and surface area to volume ratio to explain why rate of supply limits size, with three named exchange surfaces.

Heart rate is adjusted so that the rate of oxygen delivery matches the rate of respiration. The sinoatrial node sets the rhythm, and the atrioventricular node delays the wave of excitation before it passes down the bundle of His and the Purkyne tissue, so the atria empty before the ventricles contract. During exercise, carbon dioxide from respiration lowers blood pH; chemoreceptors in the carotid arteries and aorta detect this and send impulses to the cardiac centre in the medulla oblongata, which sends more impulses along sympathetic neurones to the sinoatrial node. Heart rate rises, and because cardiac output is stroke volume times heart rate, more blood reaches the muscles each minute.

Full control pathway from stimulus to effector, and the cardiac output relationship links it back to rate.

The rate at which bacteria reproduce explains how quickly antibiotic resistance spreads. Bacteria divide by binary fission, some in about 20 minutes, so a single resistant mutant can give rise to a very large population within a day. When an antibiotic is used it acts as a selection pressure: bacteria without the resistance allele die, while resistant bacteria survive, reproduce and pass the allele on, so its frequency rises rapidly. Because mutations arise at random and generation times are so short, new resistance can appear faster than new antibiotics are developed.

Correct selection argument (the antibiotic selects, it does not cause the mutation) tied to generation time. A little more on population growth would have lifted it further.

Level 3 · 11 of 25

Three relevant areas, but the rate link is missing from one and the detail is at GCSE level in places. The long introduction earns nothing.

Speed and rate are important in biology because lots of things need to happen quickly. In this essay I will talk about enzymes, nerves and the heart, and why speed and rate matter to organisms.

Introduction listing what is coming: no marks.

Enzymes increase the rate of reactions by lowering the activation energy. The substrate fits into the active site and forms an enzyme-substrate complex. When it gets too hot the enzyme is denatured because the active site changes shape, so the rate goes down.

Linked to rate and correct, but brief: no bonds named in denaturation and no control of rate.

Nerve impulses are faster in myelinated neurones because the impulse jumps between the nodes of Ranvier. This is called saltatory conduction. This means animals can respond quickly to danger, which increases their chance of survival.

Linked and accurate, but only one factor and no mechanism for why the impulse jumps.

The heart has a pacemaker called the sinoatrial node which makes the heart beat. The electrical impulse spreads across the atria and then to the atrioventricular node and down the bundle of His to the ventricles, which contract.

Relevant, but it never says how or why the rate changes, so the link to the title is missing.

The importance of accurate copying in living organisms

Level 5 · 23 of 25

A strong top-band model with several distinct areas of specification biology linked to copying. With no developed beyond-specification example, 23 is the highest available mark.

Before a cell divides, its DNA must be copied accurately. DNA helicase breaks the hydrogen bonds between complementary bases, so the double helix unwinds and both strands act as templates. Free DNA nucleotides pair with the exposed bases, adenine with thymine and cytosine with guanine, so the base sequence of each new strand is set by the template. DNA polymerase then joins adjacent nucleotides in condensation reactions, forming phosphodiester bonds and working in the 5' to 3' direction. Each new molecule keeps one original strand, which Meselson and Stahl showed with DNA containing heavy nitrogen: this semi-conservative replication keeps the copy faithful to the original.

Accurate enzymes and bonds (helicase breaks hydrogen bonds; polymerase makes phosphodiester bonds) and the copying link in every step.

Accurate copying is only useful if the copies are shared out accurately, which is what mitosis does. After replication in interphase each chromosome consists of two sister chromatids joined at the centromere. At metaphase spindle fibres attach to each centromere and the chromosomes line up at the equator; in anaphase the chromatids are pulled to opposite poles. Each daughter cell therefore receives a full, identical copy of the genetic information, which is why mitosis can be used for growth, the repair of tissues and asexual reproduction.

Explains how the spindle makes sure copies are shared exactly, linked back to growth and repair.

Genes are also copied into RNA so that proteins with the right primary structure can be made. In transcription, RNA polymerase joins RNA nucleotides complementary to the template strand, forming pre-mRNA, and splicing removes the introns. In translation, each mRNA codon on the ribosome pairs with the complementary anticodon of a tRNA carrying a specific amino acid, and the amino acids are joined by peptide bonds. Because the code is a non-overlapping triplet code, an accurate copy of the base sequence gives exactly the right sequence of amino acids, and so the right tertiary structure.

Transcription and translation described as two copying steps, with precise terms throughout.

The importance of accurate copying is clearest when it fails. A gene mutation is a change in the base sequence, which can arise spontaneously during replication and more often after exposure to mutagenic agents such as ionising radiation. A deletion of one base causes a frameshift, so every codon after it is read differently and the protein is usually non-functional. A substitution may have no effect, because the code is degenerate, or it may change one amino acid, altering the tertiary structure so that an enzyme's active site is no longer complementary to its substrate.

Explains different outcomes of copying errors and why the degenerate code sometimes protects.

When copying errors hit the genes that control the cell cycle, the result can be cancer. Tumour suppressor genes normally slow cell division and trigger repair or cell death when DNA is damaged; if a mutation inactivates them, damaged cells keep dividing. A mutation in a proto-oncogene can create an oncogene that stimulates division all the time. Abnormal methylation has similar effects: hypermethylation of a tumour suppressor gene switches it off. The result is uncontrolled mitosis and a tumour, which is malignant if it invades nearby tissue and spreads.

Links the failure of accurate copying to loss of control of division, with both gene types and epigenetic changes.

Organisms also benefit from copies that are deliberately not identical. In meiosis, homologous chromosomes pair and crossing over exchanges alleles between non-sister chromatids, and independent segregation produces new combinations of chromosomes in the haploid gametes. Random fertilisation adds more variation. This variation is the raw material for natural selection, so the balance between accurate copying in mitosis and new combinations in meiosis matters to a species.

A sharp contrast that stretches the title well.

Level 3 · 12 of 25

Relevant biology from three areas, but the depth is uneven and one paragraph is off the title. The copying link is made in most paragraphs, but mutation is described only in outline.

DNA is copied by semi-conservative replication. The two strands separate and free nucleotides join onto each strand by complementary base pairing, with A pairing with T and C with G. DNA polymerase joins the nucleotides together, so you end up with two identical copies.

Linked and correct, but no helicase and no named bonds: GCSE-plus rather than A-level depth.

A nucleotide is made of a phosphate group, a pentose sugar and a nitrogenous base. In DNA the sugar is deoxyribose and in RNA it is ribose. RNA also has uracil instead of thymine.

Accurate structure, but nothing is copied: off the title as written.

Mitosis produces two genetically identical cells for growth and repair. The chromosomes are copied first and then separated by the spindle, so each new cell gets a copy of every chromosome.

Linked, but very brief.

Sometimes mistakes happen when DNA is copied and this is called a mutation. Mutations can change the protein that is made, which could mean the protein does not work. Mutations can be caused by radiation.

Linked but outline only: no named mutation types, no frameshift, no link to tertiary structure.

In conclusion, copying accurately is important so that cells have the correct DNA and make the correct proteins.

A one-line conclusion: harmless but earns nothing.

Write your own

Questions people ask

How is the A-level Biology essay marked?

It is the last question on Paper 3: one essay from a choice of two titles, 25 marks, marked in five levels. The level depends on the depth and accuracy of the biology and how well each topic area is tied to the title.

How many topics should the essay cover?

Recent AQA marking guidance looks for at least four relevant topic areas for the top levels, each developed at A-level depth. Four thin paragraphs do not reach the top: depth matters as much as breadth.

Do I need an introduction and conclusion?

No. They earn no marks on their own. Start with your first topic area and say in its first sentence how it answers the title.

Independent practice for AQA A-level Biology (7402), not endorsed by AQA.

Privacy · Terms