Plan A: agree
Judgement: Select committees are the most effective route because their scrutiny is detailed, cross-party and less partisan.
- Independence. Since the 2010 Wright reforms, most departmental select committee chairs are elected by the whole House and members are elected within party groups, not picked by the whips, so they question ministers with more freedom. Counter: Places are shared out broadly by party strength, so the government side still has a majority on most committees.
- Depth of evidence. Committees take written and oral evidence over months, and the Public Accounts Committee reports on whether public money was well spent. Counter: Reports are only advisory: the government can reject the recommendations.
- Comparison. Prime Minister's Questions is short and often point-scoring, so committee hearings, including the Liaison Committee's sessions with the Prime Minister, test policy in more detail. Counter: PMQs reaches a far larger public audience.