A-level Politics essay planner

Question type

Up to 160 characters

Edexcel A-level Politics

Three themes in 45 minutes

Three themes, both sides
  1. 1Representation

    2024's disproportionality versus the constituency link.

  2. 2Government

    Single-party majorities versus 2010 and 2017 hung parliaments.

  3. 3Alternatives

    AMS in Scotland and the 2011 AV result.

  • Theme, argument and counter-argument
  1. 0 to 5 minPlan: three themes, the evidence for each side, and your line.
  2. 5 to 8 minIntroduction: define the key term, name the criterion and state your line.
  3. 8 to 18 minTheme 1: argument with evidence, the strongest counter-argument, mini-judgement.
  4. 18 to 28 minTheme 2: the same.
  5. 28 to 38 minTheme 3: the same.
  6. 38 to 43 minConclusion: your judgement, the criterion that decides it and when it holds.
  7. 43 to 45 minCheck dates, names and figures.
  • Weigh the view and the alternative in balance. A one-sided essay is held at Level 2: 12 marks at most.
  • On Paper 2, draw on Paper 1 (parties, elections, democracy or the core ideas), or Level 5 is out of reach.
  • Judge in every paragraph, not only at the end.

Check your own coverage

0 of 6 checks covered by you

Add a precise fact or example that supports your argument.

Which judgement follows?

An essay compares electoral systems using representation as its criterion. Which judgement best weighs the arguments?

Two plans that disagree

Evaluate the view that select committees are now the most effective way for Parliament to scrutinise the government. (30 marks, practice question)

Plan A: agree

Judgement: Select committees are the most effective route because their scrutiny is detailed, cross-party and less partisan.

  1. Independence. Since the 2010 Wright reforms, most departmental select committee chairs are elected by the whole House and members are elected within party groups, not picked by the whips, so they question ministers with more freedom. Counter: Places are shared out broadly by party strength, so the government side still has a majority on most committees.
  2. Depth of evidence. Committees take written and oral evidence over months, and the Public Accounts Committee reports on whether public money was well spent. Counter: Reports are only advisory: the government can reject the recommendations.
  3. Comparison. Prime Minister's Questions is short and often point-scoring, so committee hearings, including the Liaison Committee's sessions with the Prime Minister, test policy in more detail. Counter: PMQs reaches a far larger public audience.

Plan B: disagree

Judgement: Select committees add detail and pressure, but they cannot make the government act on their recommendations; votes in the Commons and amendments in the Lords can force changes more directly.

  1. Power to change policy. Committee recommendations are not binding. Defeats on Commons votes and backbench rebellions can force a government to change course. Counter: A government with a large majority rarely loses votes, which makes committees relatively more useful.
  2. The House of Lords. The Lords can amend and delay bills and often forces concessions in 'ping-pong' between the Houses. Counter: Under the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949 most Commons bills can become law without the Lords' consent after a delay of about a year, and the Lords is unelected.
  3. Limits on committees. Committees can summon witnesses, but they have few ways to enforce attendance if someone refuses, so some scrutiny is avoided. Counter: Most ministers do attend, and a refusal itself draws public criticism.

Both can reach the top levels: the marks follow how well each side is weighed, not which side is chosen.

Revise one paragraph

Select committees are good at scrutiny because they ask ministers questions. This means they hold the government to account.

Write it and ask Mia

Your result

Three themes in 45 minutes. For "Evaluate the view that first past the post is no longer suitable for UK general elections.": Representation; Government; Alternatives. Weigh both sides in each theme, then judge.

Marks

10 AO1 · 10 AO2 · 10 AO3

Time

45 minutes

Themes

3

A-level Politics Pro

Get an A or your money back

£119 once

Price rises to £199 on 1 January. Save £80 by joining before then.

At least 12 months' access

By paying you agree to our Terms and get access straight away, which ends your 14-day cancellation right.

No VAT is charged. Conditions

A source answer that does not use both views in a balanced way, or an essay that does not weigh the alternative, is held at Level 2: 12 marks at most.

Questions people ask

How are the marks split on a 30-mark answer?

Ten marks each for knowledge (AO1), analysis (AO2) and evaluation (AO3). A 24-mark ideas answer splits 8, 8 and 8.

What happens if I only argue one side?

A source answer that does not use both views in a balanced way, or an essay that does not weigh the alternative, is held at Level 2: 12 marks at most.

How long should I spend?

About 45 minutes on each 30-mark answer and 30 minutes on the 24-mark ideas question, which fits the two-hour paper.

Do I need thinkers in an ideas answer?

Yes. Without an appropriate specified thinker, or with only one side considered, an ideas answer is held at Level 2: 9 marks at most.

Keep going

How we work this out

What it does

Plan the argument, check your evidence and reach a justified judgement.

The extended questions on Edexcel A-level Politics Papers 1 and 2: the 30-mark source question, the 30-mark essay and the 24-mark ideas question.

Method

  1. Each question type carries Pearson's split of marks between knowledge (AO1), analysis (AO2) and evaluation (AO3).
  2. The rules come from Pearson's question-specific guidance: the balance rule for source questions and essays, and the thinker rule for ideas questions.
  3. A question from the course uses the themes of its own plan. A typed question is matched to a topic by its key words, and the topic supplies three themes, each with an argument and a counter-argument.
  4. The timing splits the suggested 45 or 30 minutes into planning, three themed paragraphs and a conclusion.
  5. A student-attested coverage checklist counts selected evidence, analysis, comparison and judgement checks. It never assigns marks or predicts a grade. The original judgement task checks whether a conclusion follows from a stated criterion.

Independent practice for Pearson Edexcel A-level Politics (9PL0), not endorsed by Pearson.

Privacy · Terms