What did the 2019 Miller/Cherry case decide?
- The Prime Minister's prorogation of Parliament was unlawful.
- It prevented Parliament from scrutinising the government.
- The prorogation was void.
Answer That the prorogation of Parliament was unlawful
A-level Politics revision · UK government
The UK Supreme Court is the final court of appeal for civil cases and for criminal cases outside Scotland, independent from government (security of tenure, salaries protected, appointment by a commission). It cannot strike down Acts of Parliament but can declare them incompatible with the Human Rights Act and rule on government actions (judicial review), as in Miller (2017, 2019). The balance between executive and Parliament depends on majorities.
Watch out The Supreme Court cannot overturn an Act of Parliament because of parliamentary sovereignty.
What did the 2019 Miller/Cherry case decide?
Answer That the prorogation of Parliament was unlawful
What can the Supreme Court issue if an Act conflicts with the Human Rights Act?
Which is a feature that protects judicial independence?
Evaluate whether the Supreme Court has become too political.
Answer Cases like Miller put it at the centre of political disputes, but it rules on law, not policy, and cannot overturn statute. It protects the rule of law rather than acting politically, though critics disagree.
A-level Politics Pro, Pearson Edexcel 9PL0
£119 once
Price rises to £199 on 1 January. Save £80 by joining before then.
At least 12 months of access
No VAT is charged.