Why is humanitarian intervention controversial?
- It overrides state sovereignty.
- It may hide strategic interests.
- Interventions such as Libya (2011) have had poor outcomes.
Answer It overrides sovereignty and may serve the interveners' interests
A-level Politics revision · Global politics
Human rights are protected by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948), the International Court of Justice (disputes between states), the International Criminal Court (individuals, for genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity) and the European Court of Human Rights. Humanitarian intervention means using force to protect people in another state; the Responsibility to Protect (2005) covers genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity: if a state manifestly fails to protect its people, the Security Council may authorise collective action.
Watch out The ICJ hears cases between states; the ICC tries individuals.
Why is humanitarian intervention controversial?
Answer It overrides sovereignty and may serve the interveners' interests
Which court tries individuals for genocide and war crimes?
The Responsibility to Protect (R2P) says that:
Evaluate the effectiveness of international human rights institutions.
Answer The ICC has convicted some war criminals and the ECtHR enforces rights in Europe. But major powers are not ICC members, rulings depend on state cooperation and interventions are selective. They are more effective in setting standards than enforcing them.
A-level Politics Pro, Pearson Edexcel 9PL0
£119 once
Price rises to £199 on 1 January. Save £80 by joining before then.
At least 12 months of access
No VAT is charged.