A-level Politics revision · USA politics

The Supreme Court: judicial or political?

The idea

Judicial activism means justices actively shaping policy, often by striking down laws or overturning precedent; judicial restraint means deferring to elected branches and precedent (stare decisis). Critics argue the Court acts as an unelected 'super legislature'. Defenders argue it protects the Constitution and minorities, and it has no power to enforce its rulings itself.

  1. Define activism and restraint.
  2. Use cases as evidence for each.
  3. Assess whether the Court is a political body.

Watch out Activism is not the same as liberalism: conservative courts can be activist too.

See it worked

Worked example

Why do critics call the Supreme Court a 'super legislature'?

  1. Its rulings settle major policy questions.
  2. Justices are unelected and serve for life.
  3. Its constitutional rulings can only be reversed by amendment or a later Court.

Answer Unelected justices make decisions with the effect of policy

Your turn

Question 11 mark

Judicial restraint means:

Choose one
Question 21 mark

Which is a limit on the Supreme Court's power?

Choose one
Question 310 marks

Evaluate whether the Supreme Court is a political rather than a judicial body.

Write your answer, then see a model answer
  1. Arguments both ways.
  2. Judgement.

Answer Its rulings settle political issues, appointments are partisan and justices often split along ideological lines. But it rules on legal and constitutional grounds, follows legal reasoning and sometimes defies the President who appointed a justice. It is a judicial body with major political effects.

A-level Politics Pro, Pearson Edexcel 9PL0

A-level Politics Pro

£119 once

Price rises to £199 on 1 January. Save £80 by joining before then.

At least 12 months of access

By paying you agree to our Terms and get access straight away, which ends your 14-day cancellation right.

No VAT is charged.

Independent practice for Pearson Edexcel A-level Politics (9PL0), not endorsed by Pearson.

Privacy · Terms