Explain the security dilemma.
- A state builds up arms for its own defence.
- Others see this as a threat and arm too.
- Both end up less secure.
Answer Defensive arming makes others feel threatened, so all become less secure
A-level Politics revision · Global politics
The security dilemma is a realist idea: when one state arms for defence, others feel threatened and arm too, raising tension. Hedley Bull's 'anarchical society' argues that, although there is no world government, states form a society with shared rules, such as diplomacy and international law. Liberals add that institutions and norms can reduce the dilemma.
Watch out The security dilemma means defensive moves can still make everyone less secure.
Explain the security dilemma.
Answer Defensive arming makes others feel threatened, so all become less secure
Who argued that states form an 'anarchical society'?
Which is an example of a security dilemma?
Evaluate whether the anarchic system makes conflict inevitable.
Answer Realists argue anarchy and the security dilemma drive conflict. But states cooperate through diplomacy, law and institutions, as Bull and liberals argue, and most states are at peace most of the time. Anarchy makes conflict possible, not inevitable.
A-level Politics Pro, Pearson Edexcel 9PL0
£119 once
Price rises to £199 on 1 January. Save £80 by joining before then.
At least 12 months of access
No VAT is charged.