A-level Psychology revision · Social influence

Explaining obedience

The idea

Milgram proposed the agentic state: people obey by seeing themselves as agents carrying out another's wishes, not responsible for their actions; the autonomous state is acting on one's own conscience. Moral strain arises when we act against our conscience. Legitimacy of authority comes from a hierarchical society in which people accept those with recognised authority.

  1. Agentic shift: autonomous → agentic.
  2. Binding factors reduce moral strain (e.g. blaming the victim).
  3. Legitimate authority: uniforms, institutions.

Watch out In the agentic state, people still feel moral strain; they just shift responsibility.

See it worked

Worked example

A soldier says he was 'just following orders'. Which explanation fits?

  1. He sees himself as acting for an authority.
  2. He does not feel responsible.
  3. The agentic state.

Answer The agentic state

Your turn

Question 11 mark

What is the autonomous state?

Choose one
Question 21 mark

Which supports legitimacy of authority?

Choose one
Question 32 marks

Outline one limitation of the agentic state explanation.

Write your answer, then see a model answer
  1. Name the limitation.
  2. Give evidence.

Answer It cannot explain why some participants disobeyed even in the agentic setting, such as a third in Milgram's baseline study; personality differences may matter.

A-level Psychology Pro, AQA 7182

A-level Psychology Pro

£129 once

Price rises to £199 on 1 January. Save £70 by joining before then.

At least 12 months of access

By paying you agree to our Terms and get access straight away, which ends your 14-day cancellation right.
Start free

No VAT is charged.