Why are field experiments in schools ethically difficult?
- Pupils may be affected without knowing.
- Some might be disadvantaged by the treatment.
- Children are vulnerable.
Answer Children may be harmed or deceived without consent
A-level Sociology revision · Methods in context (education)
Lab experiments in schools are rare because classrooms are complex and manipulating pupils raises ethical issues. Field experiments, such as Rosenthal and Jacobson's study of teacher expectations, take place in real schools. The comparative method can compare schools or policies using existing data.
Watch out Deliberately disadvantaging some pupils for an experiment would be unethical.
Why are field experiments in schools ethically difficult?
Answer Children may be harmed or deceived without consent
Which famous field experiment studied teacher expectations?
Why is it hard to control variables in school experiments?
Outline two reasons why lab experiments are rarely used to study education.
Answer A lab cannot capture the complexity and natural behaviour of a real classroom, so ecological validity is low, and manipulating pupils' education may harm them and raises consent issues.
A-level Sociology Pro, AQA 7192
£119 once
Price rises to £199 on 1 January. Save £80 by joining before then.
At least 12 months of access
No VAT is charged.