A-level Sociology revision · Research methods and theory

Experiments and the comparative method

The idea

Laboratory experiments control variables to find cause and effect but are artificial and raise ethical issues. Field experiments take place in natural settings (Rosenthal and Jacobson), with less control. The comparative method compares groups or societies to identify causes without manipulation (Durkheim). Sociologists rarely use lab experiments.

  1. Lab: control and reliability, but artificial, small samples, ethical issues.
  2. Field: more natural, less control.
  3. Comparative: 'thought experiment' using existing data.

Watch out Lab experiments struggle in sociology because social behaviour is complex and changes in artificial settings.

See it worked

Worked example

Why do sociologists rarely use laboratory experiments?

  1. Society cannot be recreated in a lab.
  2. People behave unnaturally when observed.
  3. Many experiments would be unethical.

Answer Artificiality, the Hawthorne effect and ethics

Your turn

Question 11 mark

Rosenthal and Jacobson's study of teacher expectations was a:

Choose one
Question 21 mark

Durkheim's comparison of suicide rates across societies used:

Choose one
Question 34 marks

Outline two ethical problems with field experiments.

Write your answer, then see a model answer
  1. First problem.
  2. Second problem.

Answer Participants usually do not know they are being studied, so there is no informed consent, and the experiment may harm them, as with pupils wrongly labelled.

A-level Sociology Pro, AQA 7192

A-level Sociology Pro

£119 once

Price rises to £199 on 1 January. Save £80 by joining before then.

At least 12 months of access

By paying you agree to our Terms and get access straight away, which ends your 14-day cancellation right.
Start free

No VAT is charged.

Independent practice for AQA A-level Sociology (7192), not endorsed by AQA.

Privacy · Terms