A-level Politics revision · USA politics

Comparing UK and US constitutions

The idea

Comparative politics uses three theories: rational choice (individuals act in their own interests), cultural (shared values and history shape behaviour) and structural (institutions and rules shape behaviour). The US Constitution is codified, entrenched and federal with a strict separation of powers; the UK constitution is uncodified, flexible and unitary (with devolution) with a fusion of powers.

  1. Compare codified and uncodified, federal and unitary.
  2. Compare separation and fusion of powers.
  3. Apply a theory to explain a difference.

Watch out Structural theory explains differences through institutions, such as the US separation of powers producing gridlock.

See it worked

Worked example

Use structural theory to explain why US Presidents struggle to pass laws.

  1. The Constitution separates the President from Congress.
  2. Congress may be controlled by the other party.
  3. So institutions, not individuals, create gridlock.

Answer The separation of powers built into the Constitution creates gridlock

Your turn

Question 11 mark

Which theory explains political behaviour through shared values and history?

Choose one
Question 21 mark

Which describes the UK but not the US system?

Choose one
Question 310 marks

Evaluate whether the US Constitution protects rights better than the UK constitution.

Write your answer, then see a model answer
  1. Comparison.
  2. Judgement.

Answer The US entrenched Bill of Rights lets courts strike down laws, while UK courts cannot strike down Acts of Parliament: under the Human Rights Act they read laws compatibly where possible and can issue declarations of incompatibility. But US protection depends on the Court's interpretation, as Dobbs shows, and the UK has strong conventions. The US offers stronger legal protection, though not always better outcomes.

A-level Politics Pro, Pearson Edexcel 9PL0

A-level Politics Pro

£119 once

Price rises to £199 on 1 January. Save £80 by joining before then.

At least 12 months of access

By paying you agree to our Terms and get access straight away, which ends your 14-day cancellation right.

No VAT is charged.

Independent practice for Pearson Edexcel A-level Politics (9PL0), not endorsed by Pearson.

Privacy · Terms