Why is Congress more independent of the executive than Parliament?
- The executive does not sit in Congress.
- Members are elected separately from the President.
- Party discipline is weaker.
Answer Separation of powers and weaker party discipline
A-level Politics revision · USA politics
Congress is more powerful than Parliament: it is separate from the executive, has strong committees and both chambers are elected and roughly equal. Parliament is dominated by a government with a majority, and the Lords is unelected and subordinate. The President has a separate mandate through the Electoral College and cannot be removed by a vote of confidence; the Prime Minister depends on the Commons majority.
Watch out The US Senate is more powerful than the House of Lords because it is elected and has equal legislative power.
Why is Congress more independent of the executive than Parliament?
Answer Separation of powers and weaker party discipline
Which can remove a UK Prime Minister but has no US equivalent for the President?
Which second chamber is more powerful?
Evaluate whether the US President is more powerful than the UK Prime Minister.
Answer The President has a separate national mandate, a fixed term and commands the military. But a PM with a large majority controls the legislature and can pass laws easily, while the President faces a separate, often hostile Congress. A PM with a majority has more domestic power; the President has more security of tenure.
A-level Politics Pro, Pearson Edexcel 9PL0
£119 once
Price rises to £199 on 1 January. Save £80 by joining before then.
At least 12 months of access
No VAT is charged.